In the 1990s, Tunisia was living under a police state and a corrupt dictatorship, which ultimately drove the people to revolt in 2011. During 23 years of absolute power, the regime organized four so-called presidential elections, which were mere farces, with the dictator’s victory a foregone conclusion and the usual results exceeding 90 per cent of the so-called votes.
As in any dictatorship, Tunisia had no constitutional court before which such results could be challenged. It was during the very first of these so-called elections that I became aware of a significant gap in international law. In dictatorships, there is no national constitutional court and if there is, it is not independent. The only way to challenge such elections and the legitimacy of the regime organizing them is to bring the matter before an International Constitutional Court (ICCo).
An international court to challenge undemocratic elections
Admittedly, the agreement on the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) in 1998 was a major step forward in the development of international law, but it deals with individual international crimes, whereas the priority must be to prevent them in the first place.
The ICCo could exist because the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights constitute, de facto, the international constitution to which all states have acceded.
I began to dream that any national election won through violence and lies would be declared invalid by the ICCo following a complaint from the democratic opposition, and that this would hasten the fall of dictatorship. It could also rule on national laws that contravene human rights. Of course, its rulings might be ignored in the absence of a renewed Security Council capable of enforcing international law. But its moral authority would make it more difficult for dictatorships to exercise absolute power and would shorten their duration.
In 2011, following the fall of the dictatorship, I was elected President of the Republic by the Constituent Assembly. During my term of office, I did everything I could to ensure that the constitution of the new democracy, adopted in 2014, was as progressive as possible in terms of civil liberties and, above all, that a constitutional court was established to safeguard it.
I also revived the dream of the ICCo. I asked the former Dean of the Faculty of Law at Tunis University to convene a gathering of leading international legal experts to discuss the project. The meeting took place at the Presidential Palace in 2013. Based on the recommendations of these eminent specialists, a detailed draft was drawn up by my legal advisers. In September 2014, I personally handed over the Tunisian Republic’s official proposal to establish an ICCo to Ban Ki-moon, the UN Secretary-General, in New York.
In 2014, the Tunisian Republic proposed an International Constitutional Court
I was advised to involve at least twenty states in the project, and I drew up my first list, comprising, of course, democratic states from around the world. I was under no illusions as to the hostility the project would provoke from regimes such as those in Russia or China, but I wanted to bring the debate to the global stage.
Unfortunately, the return to power in 2014 of a president from the former regime, and in 2019 of a president who abolished the constitution in 2023 and reinstated the dictatorship, put an end to my two projects.
The irony of the situation is that today Tunisia has no constitutional court, that the ICCo seems more like a utopia than ever, and that I am condemned to live in exile once again after being sentenced in absentia to 39 years’ imprisonment for treason because I denounced the abolition of the democratic constitution and the return of dictatorship in 2021.
This situation is part of a broader context of the decline of democracy across the world, the rise of populism and fascism, widespread rearmament, and the erosion of human rights values.
The contempt shown by major powers such as the USA towards the International Court of Justice in The Hague or the ICC, coupled with the ineffectiveness of UN institutions, demonstrates that we are heading towards a lawless world rather than one governed by values and a strong, respected system of international law.
All great achievements were once dreams
Under these circumstances, what is the point of talking about creating a body that would, in any case, be met with rejection by all the world’s dictatorships?
It is worth recalling that the idea of an international criminal court to ensure compliance with international humanitarian law first emerged in 1872 with Gustave Moynier.
Combating impunity by bringing the perpetrators of the most serious crimes to justice at the international level must have seemed rather utopian at that time and throughout the wars of the 20th century. Yet it was precisely the horrors of these wars and the clear responsibility of those who instigated them that ultimately led to the creation of the ICC in 2002. It therefore took more than one hundred years for an intellectual’s dream to become a reality. Why should the ICCo not follow the same path as the ICC?
To conclude, let us recall the key principles governing the relationship between dreams and reality in politics: Human beings only dream of projects they are capable of achieving; not all dreams come true, but the greatest achievements all were once dreams. For a dream to become a reality, the recipe is a great deal of faith, hard work and perseverance.
This is what lies ahead for us as we stick to our commitment to building a safe and peaceful world governed by the rule of law, of which the ICCo would be the finest achievement.